Ladder Growth Test of the Month

Test of the Month: How Ladder Launched a Facebook Video Ad With an 11% CTR

We’ve launched thousands of marketing tests, and let’s be honest: we’ve seen some winners and a few losers (like Reddit Ads).

But we want to start highlighting the “big wins”. Enter Test of the Month!

The Test of the Month competition is an opportunity for everyone at Ladder to share their innovative, impactful, and clever work from the previous month. It’s a chance for great ideas to be recognized and then shared.

We grade each test on three criteria:

  • Innovation – Has this type of test never been done before? Did it require creative thinking to implement? Is it in an area we don’t cover often enough?
  • Impact – Is this test likely to make a large impact? Did it perform better than expected? Does this test set the client up for a big strategic win?
  • Use of data – Did you have a strong hypothesis for this test based on sound data? Did you do any interesting analysis in order to dnd the inspiration or justification for this test?

Without further adieu, this month’s winners are…


Third Place: Impression Boosting Responsive Ads in Google AdWords

Test of the Month - Jakub Fidala

Growth Strategist Jakub Fidala created and launched responsive ads in Google AdWords for a Polish home decor brand. Responsive ads increase impressions as they fit into any placement. This allows them to get more impressions which provide us with more data for bid optimization.

“The great thing about responsive ads is that they can fit all available ad placements across Google Display Network (GDN),” Jakub says. “They are shown in display ads, text ads, and native ads. A few years ago, it was common practice to add text ads next to the image in GDN in order to increase views for placements where we couldn’t show one or another.”

“They require only 2 images and a logo, which makes much less work for graphic designers. We don’t have to put any text (there is a limit, 20% on image) as we use it with additional text.”

Over a test period of four days, Jakub compared the performance of static ads to responsive ads. The static ads earned:

Clicks: 229

Impressions: 143,936

CTR: 0.16%

Avg. CPC: $0.12 

Cost: $27.79 

In comparison, here’s how his responsive ads performed:

Clicks: 531 (an increase of 131.88%)

Impressions: 330,236 (an increase of 129.4%)

CTR: 0.16%

Avg. CPC: $0.12 USD

Cost: $60.79 USD

Although the responsive ads weren’t able to affect the CPC and CTR, Jakub says the information collected from this test, will help him optimize his responsive ads in the future even better. 

Responsive Ad

This tactic requires media budget

In today’s world, users are viewing advertisements on a wide array of displays. Utilize the responsive ad feature within Adwords for running on the Google Display Network (GDN). Your ad will change to the size needed for placement, allowing for better readability and more conversions.

Success Rate:

7%

Difficulty:

Beginner

Marketing:

1h

Design:                    

1h

Responsive Facebook Ads Tactic

Second Place: Cartoony Creative Refresh

Test of the Month - Andrew

Coming in second place is Growth Strategist Andrew (“Andy”) Robertson, who used a creative tactic to scale Facebook Lead Ads for a cloud-connected accounting app.

After introducing both a copy and creative refresh across Facebook & LinkedIn, Andy’s goal for this month’s test was to “introduce more new creative variants which have a different style from the existing cartoon variants we have been running with. This will further reduce ad frequency while increasing the total number of leads.”

Did he reach his goal?

“Of the two existing/scaling lead gen campaigns we ran through May, we had a CPL of $54.71 and lead form conversion rate of 14.45%,” he says. “Our creative refresh slashed the CPL in half, driving leads priced at $25.35 with a conversion rate of 23.83%!” In other words, Andy’s creative refresh test lowered his CPL by 53%!

Looking forward, Andy says his creative test has made a permanent impact on his client’s site. “With this refresh,” Andy says, “we’ve instilled more confidence into the client – they love the creative, we’ve shown them cartoon imagery performs much better than their old lifestyle, and we position them nicely regarding the direction they need to take when it comes to future creative.” 

Creative Refresh

This tactic requires media budget

Changing even just a few inconsequential elements in your ad creative can cause the advertising platform to treat it as a new ad and show it to a wider audience. Make simple tweaks like color, text positioning, element sizes, etc… to give your ad a refresh.

Success Rate:

70%

Marketing:

1h

Design:

2h

Creative Refresh Tactic

First Place: Perfect 10 (Relevance Score) Promo Video

Test of the Month - Morgan

This month’s Test of the Month winner is Growth Strategist Morgan Schofield for his experiment on a SaaS client that wants to drive more top-of-funnel traffic to their site for conversions to email capture.

For this experiment, Morgan set out to benchmark the new promo videos to advertise the platform and the USP to determine if people are more likely to engage in videos on social media so we expect to see a higher CTR than static images. He also used the Unbounce CRO landing page to optimise the conversion environment.

“I created the promotional videos using the digital video service, Promo, for $25 per video,” says Morgan. “I benchmarked this test to the client’s email list and scaled to target crypto audiences in-line with their USP. The budget started at $50/day and I scaled it to $150/day.

Keeping in mind that video ads have an average CTR of 1.84%, Morgan’s results were absolutely incredible!

“Of the four videos launched, the video ad got 11% CTR, a CPA of $3.84, and drove 54 new leads on the landing page (to date),” says Morgan. “It also scored 10 on Facebook’s relevance score — I’ve never seen a 10.”

Morgan says this experiment opens up new opportunities to experiment with new ad formats to improve conversion rates in the future. “The success of this test has reaffirmed the value of Ladder to this client and illuminated opportunities for further optimization deeper in the funnel,” says Morgan.

Congratulations Morgan on winning Test of the Month!

Video Ad

This tactic requires media budget

Using an auto-play video in an ad can drive a deeper emotional connection and can be much more engaging. In our experience the CPM of video ads is much lower due to the high engagement rate and relevance score. This can be a very cost effective way to reach a much larger audience than normal, in a less obtrusive, more engaging way.

Success Rate:

57%

Difficulty:

Intermediate

Marketing:

4h

Design:

4h

Video Promo Ads

All of the tactics our strategists used are currently available in the Ladder Playbook, our public database of over 800+ acquisition, conversion, and retention tactics. Use the Ladder Playbook to find new tactics to execute in your marketing campaigns!